Owning a car involves making countless decisions, especially when considering which upgrades are worth the investment. However, not every shiny add-on delivers on its promises.

In fact, some upgrades end up being more of a regret than a reward, offering little value or satisfaction for the money spent. Here’s a look at 13 car upgrades that often leave buyers with a serious case of buyer’s remorse.

Extended Warranties

Image Credit: Proxima Studio/Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $1,000 to $3,000

While they promise peace of mind, extended warranties usually cover less than expected, making them an expensive and unnecessary bet for most new car buyers.

Seat and Fabric Protection

Image Credit: welcomia/Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $150-250

Offered as a shield against stains, the reality is that seat and fabric protection is often an overpriced and unnecessary service, given the affordable alternatives available.

Dent Protection

Image Credit: Albina Gavrilovic from Getty Images/Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $200

Dent protection probably sounds tempting, but its numerous limitations can render it ineffective when you need it most, making it an upgrade that lots of people regret.

Nitrogen Tire Inflation

Image Credit: Shutter2U/Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $100

Filling your tires with nitrogen for about $100 is often marketed with promises of “better tire pressure retention” and “improved fuel efficiency”. However, considering that standard air is already 78% nitrogen, the benefits for most drivers are barely noticeable.

Vehicle Identification Number Etching

Image Credit: Molly Treece, Public domain, via Wikimedia Commons.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $200

VIN etching is sold as a theft deterrent service, but the price tag is steep compared to DIY kits available for under $30. Despite its potential security benefits, the cost doesn’t stack up, especially when more effective anti-theft options exist.

Key Replacement Plans

Image Credit: Изображения пользователя Myron Standret/ Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $200-$600

While the convenience of a replacement key plan is undeniable, the cost can quickly become excessive. With plans ranging up to $600, it’s an upgrade many find too pricey for the peace of mind it offers.

Vehicle Undercoating

Image Credit: welcomia/Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $500-$1,000

Dealerships may insist on undercoating to protect against rust and corrosion, but modern vehicles already have sufficient protection. This makes undercoating an often redundant and costly add-on.

Gap Insurance

Image Credit: 89Stocker/ Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $500-$700

Gap insurance can be wise for some, yet the dealership markup makes it worthwhile to look elsewhere. It’s a reminder to evaluate what’s included with your vehicle purchase and opt for additional services judiciously.

Paint Protection Films

Image Credit: Akifyeva Svetlana from Getty Images/ Canva Pr
  • Average Estimated Cost: $400-$1,000

Though touted as a defense against scratches and chips, paint protection films might not offer value unless you’re driving in harsh conditions or are particularly focused on maintaining a car’s appearance for resale.

Wheel and Tire Protection

Image Credit: Leo Cardelli/Pexels.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $500-$1,500

With coverage that often includes numerous exclusions, the appeal of wheel and tire protection plans can quickly diminish, leaving many to question their value.

GPS Recovery

Image Credit: Bilanol/Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: $699-$1,499

With most new vehicles featuring built-in GPS tracking, paying a premium for a GPS theft recovery device feels pointless, especially considering the monthly subscription fees involved.

Credit Life Insurance

Image Credit: Elnur/ Canva Pro.
  • Average Estimated Cost: around $.50 for every $100 borrowed annually

Though not the most expensive, credit life insurance is a questionable investment, benefiting the lender at the borrower’s expense, especially since it doesn’t offer any direct benefit to you if you’re unable to make payments due to unforeseen circumstances.

Author: Abbie Clark

Title: Author and Editor

Expertise: Automotive, Parenting, Home and Garden, Budgeting

Abbie Clark is a writer, blog, and founder of Hey She Thrives and The Bearded Bunch.

From clever car cleaning tricks to the freshest car features and reviews, Abbie loves sharing her knowledge on everything automotive. Outside of her time writing for her websites, you’ll find her fishing with her husband, playing cars with her toddler, or baking up something sweet.

Similar Posts

One Comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *